How to Choose the Right Interest Rate for a Seller-Financed Loan

Setting the right interest rate is one of the most important decisions in a seller-financed transaction. Both buyers and sellers must find a rate that is fair, competitive, and legally compliant. In this guide, we’ll explore how to select an interest rate that works for both parties, while ensuring it falls within state usury laws.

Understanding Usury Law Limits and Applicable Federal Rates

Before setting an interest rate, it’s important to know that each state has maximum allowable interest rates to protect borrowers from excessively high charges. These laws, known as usury laws, vary by state and may depend on factors such as loan amount, loan type, and whether the seller is considered a professional lender.

To find the maximum allowable rate in your state, check resources like:

• Your state’s Department of Finance or Consumer Affairs website
• The IRS's Applicable Federal Rates
• Legal and financial professionals familiar with seller-financed transactions

It’s crucial to stay compliant. Setting an interest rate above the legal limit can make a loan unenforceable, subject the seller to penalties, or even be considered a criminal act in some states.

In addition to state usury laws, seller-financed transactions should also comply with the IRS Applicable Federal Rate (AFR). The IRS sets these minimum interest rates monthly to prevent loans from being classified as below-market loans, which can trigger tax implications for the seller. Setting an interest rate at or above the AFR helps avoid potential tax penalties while ensuring the loan remains legally enforceable. You can check the current AFR rates on the IRS website.

Seller Perspective: Setting a Competitive and Fair Rate

For sellers, the goal is to set a rate that reflects both the risk of financing the transaction and the market conditions. Here are a few key considerations:

• Market Rates: Look at traditional mortgage rates as a baseline. Seller-financed loans typically have slightly higher interest rates than bank loans to account for the additional risk.
• Buyer Creditworthiness: A buyer with strong financials may warrant a lower rate, while a higher rate may be appropriate for a riskier borrower.
• Loan Term: Shorter loan terms often come with lower rates, while longer-term financing may require a higher rate to compensate for extended risk.
• Inflation and Economic Conditions: If inflation is rising, a slightly higher interest rate can help protect the seller’s long-term returns.
• Make Your Property More Marketable: Setting an interest rate slightly lower than market alternatives can attract more buyers and make your seller-financed property more competitive. A lower rate can increase affordability for buyers, leading to a faster sale and potentially better overall terms.

Buyer Perspective: Finding an Affordable Rate

For buyers, the interest rate determines the affordability of monthly payments and the total cost of the home over time. Here’s how buyers can evaluate and negotiate a fair rate:

• Compare With Market Rates: Even though seller financing rates are usually higher than traditional mortgages, they should still be reasonable.
• Negotiate Based on Financial Strength: Buyers with a steady income and lower debt-to-income ratio may be able to negotiate a lower rate.
• Understand the Total Cost: A slightly higher rate may still be manageable if the other loan terms are favorable, such as no prepayment penalties or a longer repayment period.
• Consider a Larger Down Payment: Offering a higher down payment reduces the seller’s risk, which could result in a lower interest rate.
• Factor in Property Condition: Homes that need significant repairs or updates may give you leverage to negotiate a lower interest rate. If the property requires additional investment on your part, the seller may be willing to offer better financing terms to close the deal.

Final Thoughts: Finding the Right Balance

Choosing the right interest rate in a seller-financed deal requires balance—sellers need a fair return on their investment, while buyers need an affordable loan. Both parties should research legal limits, consider market conditions, and negotiate terms to create a loan that works for both parties. By setting a reasonable and compliant interest rate, seller financing can be a win-win solution for unique real estate transactions.

Need help structuring a seller-financed loan? Promissa provides tools to guide both buyers and sellers through the process, ensuring transparent, fair, and legally compliant transactions.

‍